Nut Butters

Simple, satisfying, and peanut free — with best sellers made from just one ingredient — our nut butters deliver clean labels, bold flavor, and feel-good spoonfuls.

Front View of a Jar of Maisie Jane's Cowboy Caramel Cashew Nut Butter on a white background

Cowboy Caramel Cashew Butter (12 oz)

$ 10.95

Buy a Pack of 3 save $0.77/jarBuy a Pack of 12 save $1.31/jar Non-GMO Project Verified | Kosher Certified...

Nut Butter Bundle

$ 31.09

Introducing our NEW Conventional Nut Butter Bundle—a curated collection designed to help you find your...

Organic Nut Butter Bundle

$ 41.35

Drum roll, please! We’ve bundled up our nut butters for the ultimate tasting experience with...

Top Picks Nut Butter & Honey Bundle

$ 37.50

Introducing our Top Picked Almond Butter and Honey Bundle—the ultimate choice curated by our customers!...

Honey & Nut Butter Bundle

$ 35.45

Introducing our NEW Honey & Nut Butter Bundle—the ultimate breakfast trio to start your day...

Organic Nut Butter & Honey Bundle

$ 42.20

Introducing our NEW Honey & Nut Butter Bundle—the ultimate organic breakfast trio to kickstart your...

8 oz Nut Butter Bundle

$ 35.00

Introducing our NEW 8 oz Butters Bundle—a delightful assortment perfect for nut butter enthusiasts! This...

Creamy Cashew Butter

$ 12.65

Save when you purchase by the case (3 pack) (12 pack) Buy a Pack of...

Organic Creamy Cashew Butter

$ 15.95

Save when you purchase by the case (3 pack) (12 pack) Buy a Pack of...

Bee - Creamy Cashew Butter

$ 8.75

Save when you purchase by the case (3 pack) (12 pack) Buy a Pack of 3 ...

Holiday Nut Butter Bundle

$ 23.62

$ 23.62 ~~$ 0.00~~

Introducing our NEW Holiday Nut Butter Bundle—a festive collection designed especially for our holiday nut...

Cowboy Christmas Butter - Sea Salted Caramel Cashew

$ 8.75

$ 8.75 ~~$ 8.75~~

Save when you purchase by the case (3 pack) (12 pack)Buy a Pack of 3 save 7%Buy...

1 2 »

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Why Maisie Jane’s Nut Butters?

Maisie Jane's Nut Butter collection includes classic almond butter, creamy cashew butter, and seasonal flavored nut butter varieties. We’re committed to health and quality, using organic, non-GMO nuts and minimal added ingredients to offer a wholesome alternative to typical grocery store spreads. Our nut butters are gluten-free and crafted with environmental consciousness at the forefront. Offering smooth nut butter along with crunchy nut butter, there’s something for everyone.

We source our almonds exclusively from our own orchards and other trusted Northern California farmers. Our almond and cashew butters contain just one ingredient—no palm oil, salt, or sugar—underscoring our dedication to purity and simplicity. Each batch is handcrafted in a 100% peanut free facility, providing added peace of mind for those with peanut allergies or sensitivities. At Maisie Jane’s, we prioritize safety, sustainability, and delicious flavor in every jar.

From Our Farm To Your Table

Every product we make reflects the heart of our family farm — clean, wholesome ingredients, sustainable methods, and a passion for feeding your family well while honoring the earth we tend.

Save Our Bees

Bees are a crucial part of almond harvest. That’s why we prioritize bee-friendly farming practices to protect pollinators and sustain our orchards.

Free Shipping Over $79

Loved by thousands and shipped nationwide, our farm-crafted products come straight to your door — with free shipping on orders over $79 in the US (excludes Alaska and Hawaii).